Welcome to Coal Oil Johnny's Eatery
Coal Oil Johnny's Eatery, nestled at 117 E State St in Pleasantville, PA, embodies the heart of community dining. With a reputation for quick, affordable meals and friendly service, this eatery leaves patrons feeling at home. Breakfast is served all day, making it a favorite for dishes like the highly praised eggs benedict and BBQ pulled pork salad. Diners appreciate the attentive staff, who maintain a warm atmosphere and ensure coffee refills flow swiftly. The charm of this small-town establishment fosters personal connections among guests, creating a welcoming experience that makes you want to return.
Coal Oil Johnny's Eatery: Reviews & Ratings
Quick, good, affordable, friendly service everytime! Love this place! I wish they were open for dinner more often.
Food was pretty great! Really enjoyed the eggs benedict. Service was fast and timely. Frequently check to see if we need to refills of coffee. I would highly recommend this place for anyone looking for a good breakfast with a home-cooked feel
I had the spinach salad with BBQ Pulled Pork. It was very good. Service was attentive, warm, and friendly. We will stop again the next time we pass through there.
Went on a Sunday . The food was good and the prices were great. They close at 2 pm. Breakfast served all day. Seating is a little tight if you have an older person with a walker. But I would highly recommend it for the food.
I like visiting restaurants where you can see community happening. I was staying with a friend for the weekend and I was told this is where we have to go after church. The charm of the small town eatery is present before you even step through the door. I saw customers holding the door for one another, greeting one another, teasing as they entered the sanctuary after their church service on a Sunday afternoon. It was obvious people didn't just eat here, they interacted on a personal level. I generally skip the chains when traveling and this is why. The food was good, the prices were fair, the service was friendly, but I love seeing community on a deeper level. The waitresses knew their regulars, treated them more like family than customers but were quick to welcome an out of towner as well. If I'm ever in the area again I will definitely be returning to Coal Oil Johnny's. If I could pack a restaurant up and take it with me I would, but then Pleasantville would be a little less pleasant. This place is a must for anyone that appreciates the spirit of a small town.
I had the 12oz dry-aged strip steak with tarragon compound butter and frites...delicious!
I have never got a meal there that disappointed me. And their pies are to kill for. Services quick, food is served hot and fast. And they have a great atmosphere
Sweet little eatery, a busy place because everyone wants to eat here! With good reason! Food is fantastic staff is friendly and funny even with every table full!
Location
-
117 E State St, Pleasantville, PA 16341, United States Hotline: +1 814-589-5500
Welcome to the charming world of Coal Oil Johnny's Eatery, a delightful diner located at 117 E State St, Pleasantville, PA. This eatery has quickly garnered a reputation for its welcoming atmosphere and community-centric vibe. Patrons rave about the fast, friendly service and the home-cooked feel of its menu, making each visit a familiar experience.
Coal Oil Johnny's shines brightest during breakfast hours, a meal truly celebrated here. Customers have praised dishes like the Eggs Benedict, which is said to be particularly delightful, along with other hearty breakfast options available all day. The prices are unrealistically low for the quality you receive. You might just find yourself looking forward to returning for another round, as Edyie Reed noted in her glowing review about the eatery's affordability.
The sense of community at Coal Oil Johnny's is palpable. Jeremy Kerstetter captures this charm perfectly, describing how the warmth between regulars and staff creates an inviting environment unlike any chain restaurant. Here, you’ll see friendships formed over coffee refills, and lively conversations blooming after church services. It’s not just a meal—it's a gathering ground for friends and families. Customers like Cathy McElhinny appreciate how attentive and warm the service is, which fosters a sense of belonging.
In addition to breakfast fare, the menu also offers delightful options like a Spinach Salad topped with BBQ Pulled Pork, a dish that truly exemplifies the eatery's flair for blending flavors. Each bite combines freshness and comfort, showcasing a thoughtful approach to ingredients. Teri Middleton highlights the value for money and the friendly service, reminding us that this spot is as affordable as it is inviting.
For anyone seeking an experience that resonates with the essence of small-town life, Coal Oil Johnny's Eatery is a must-visit. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this eatery promises not just satisfying meals but also a sense of community that leaves a lasting impression.